Oatcakes and Nova Scotia Flashbacks

I spent some of my most memorable moments in Halifax, NS in the late 90s.  I lived there for two years and I loved every minute of it.

There are some foods that will forever be connected to Halifax in my mind and oatcakes are one of those foods.  My favourite cafe, The Mokka, served oatcakes half-dipped in chocolate.  They were incredible.  Moist.  Delicious.  I spent many hours sitting there writing or drawing, with a cup of coffee, or six! (gotta love free refills), and an oatcake.

In ten years, I haven’t had any oatcake that was comparable to those.  Until recently, I never considered making my own either.  That was a mistake!  Not too long ago, I was on the internet looking at recipes and something I saw made me think back on those oatcakes I used to purchase in NS. So I did a search and found a recipe for “Nova Scotian Oatcakes”.  When I mentioned it to my mother, she dug up my grandmothers recipe and shared it with me.  Since my grandmother was from Nova Scotia, we were pretty certain that her recipe would represent true N.S. goodness.  It was almost identical to the one I’d found online so I decided to try it.

No regrets. At all.

They were easy to make.  Moist.  Delicious.  Just as I remember them!  The recipe didn’t mention chocolate, so I took it upon myself to temper some milk chocolate and dip them.


Click here for the recipe or scroll to the bottom of the post.

Two things about the collection of ingredients that I need to mention.
1) There’s no cinnamon in the above picture because I decided  to add it last-minute.  It  added a nice flavour to the oatcake so I definitely recommend it.
2) You may notice that the ‘cup’ of brown sugar is slightly lacking in the picture.  This is because my sugar was ROCK hard and I had a hell of a time trying to soften it quickly.  I microwaved it in bowl along with a bowl of water, assuming the steam would soften the sugar rocks.  It did, but it took so long and eventually the water exploded, splashing the remaining sugar and melting it into a puddle.  So, the above ‘cup’ of sugar is all I could save from that disaster.

Reader Query: How do you go about softening brown sugar?  If you have to do it quickly rather than overnight, what ways have you found to be most successful?  At this point, I’m afraid I may just give in and throw out my bag o’ sugar-rock next time.  It was quite frustrating!

So, the recipe was really quite simple.  Mixed all the dry ingredients together….

Dry Ingredients

Followed by the addition of the shortening.

I keep meaning to buy a pastry blender for jobs such as this.  I’ve been told by many people that I can effectively ‘cut in’ shortening or butter with two knives but I find that awkward and I always end up falling back on … my own two hands!  A pastry blender would be quite helpful…although I have to admit that most of the time, I like getting my hands dirty, as it were.  This recipe was no exception.  (I wonder if shortening is good for the skin? My hands were quite soft afterwards!)

Batter after cutting in the shortening

Once the dough became crumbly (see picture above) I finally added the 1/4 cup of hot water.  I use my hands to mix it up and I have to say that initially I thought I had done something wrong.  Upon adding the water, the batter was insanely sticky and gooey.  I stood there for a few moments reviewing the recipe in my head, looking for errors, and in that time, I believe it was the oats that sucked up a lot of the added water.

So, my advice…add the water, mix and left the batter for two or three minutes.  It will become tacky and manageable all on its own.

At that point, it was ready to roll, literally.  I floured my counter top slightly and dumped out the ball of batter, covering it with a piece of wax paper to allow for easy rolling.

I cut my oatcakes into squares simply because that’s how they were served in Halifax, but of course you could shape them any way you please.  I did find the dough slightly sticky so the cut cakes had to be carefully manoeuvred off the counter top and onto the cookie sheet.

The final touch?  A light brushing with milk and a *slight* sprinkle of sugar:

Into the oven they went and 12 minutes later, I had lovely golden oatcakes!!

Since the oatcakes I used to eat were always half dipped in chocolate, I decided to go ahead and attempt to recreate them exactly.  As I allowed the cakes to cool in the fridge, I prepared a homemade double broiler since I didn’t have an actual one to use.  I filled the pot about half way with water, low enough that the foil/bowl wouldn’t be directly touching it, and wrapped the foil tightly around the pot opening, allowing no steam to escape.

Once the water was hot, I placed about 3/4 cup of milk chocolate chips in the bowl and stirred them until melted.  Technically, I stirred them until they were just over halfway melted, and then removed the bowl and continued stirring, which allowed the captured heat to melt the remainder without burning the chocolate.  Periodically, I would return the bowl to the broiler to absorb a bit more heat but I wouldn’t leave it there.

I had also read that milk chocolate needed to be heated to 86 degrees Fahrenheit so initially I kept track of the temperature as well.  Chocolate heats quite fast, at least it seemed to!

Dipping the oatcakes

I placed the dipped oatcakes on wax paper in the fridge.  An hour later, they were set….and absolutely delicious!


  • 2 cups rolled oats
  • 1 cup all-purpose flour
  • 1 cup brown sugar
  • 1 tsp salt
  • 3/4 cup shortening
  • 1/4 tsp baking soda
  • 1/2 tsp cinnamon
  • 1/4 cup hot water

Optional: These oatcakes are awesome dipped in chocolate!  I used approx 3/4-1 cup of melted milk chocolate chips (see above)

  1. Preheat oven to 375F.
  2. Mix dry ingredients together then cut in shortening until mixture is crumbly.
  3.  Add in hot water and stir until mixture sticks together.
  4. Turn out onto floured surface and press mixture together.
  5. Roll out to approximately 1/2 inch thick. Cut into squares or circles.
  6. Place on parchment lined cookie sheet.
  7. Brush with milk and sprinkle with white sugar.
  8. Bake in oven for 10-12 minutes, until golden around the edges.

About Amanda Pants

A bit odd, a bit eccentric, a bit loud. Kinda goth, kinda alt, kinda geeky. Crochet/cooking/reading/writing/big stompy boots/journals and a Cheshire grin! All recorded on Wordpress ;) Learning to cook with a Dash of Daring and a Pinch of Panic: ediblenoir.wordpress.com Sewing and fibre arts, creations made by moi: stitchnoir.wordpress.com Random rants and other bits and pieces: adashofnoir.wordpress.com View all posts by Amanda Pants

16 responses to “Oatcakes and Nova Scotia Flashbacks

  • karen

    Grate the hard brown sugar

  • Gauri

    Hi Amanda…I really want to try these but tiny question can i substitute shortening with something else, like coconut oil or margarine or something..thanks a lot…=)

    • Amanda Pants

      Next time I make these, I’d consider trying them with butter 🙂 I tend to prefer butter in most foods rather than shortening. You can substitute 1:1…I just find that butter may make them a tad crispier or harder than shortening.

      I don’t think coconut oil would work…but if you want to add some coconut flavour, trying added 1/4 cup of actual dried coconut 🙂

      Hope that helps!

  • Kim

    Just tried this recipe and loved it! I far prefer this to any oatmeal cookie. I can see why people double this recipe. Thanks for posting.

  • Ann Marie

    Highly addictive cookies ! You’re recipe is very close to my Granny’s recipe… 3 cups of oats and 3 cups of flour … And I often have to double that because they just disappear ! Made them for a family reunion last year. Individually boxed them for all … Well received, great snack for the trip home ! Funny I thought I had the only family crazy fot oatcake ! LoL

    • Amanda Pants

      Thanks for the comment! They’re SO good aren’t they!

      I’m having a party next weekend and after your comment I think I’m going to have to make a batch for my company! 🙂

      Be sure to try them dipped in chocolate! Yum!

  • chelsea

    I was at university at Dal and miss the oatcakes. I’ve been trying to find a recipe online, but they all look more like crackers. THESE look like oatcakes! Thank you so much for posting this! (Another variation I liked, and may try after I make your recipe once, is somehow they mixed peanut butter in with the oatcake. And still dipped it in chocolate. 🙂 yumm)

  • Alyx

    they sell clay disks (kitchen stores, canadian tire) to keep in your brown sugar to stop it from turning to rock.. with mixed results, but worth a try!

  • Frosty The Pagan

    Dear Ms. Au Contraire,

    Would you be a kindly soul and Canada Post an oatcake to my London residence. The Tim Hortons oatcakes are tasty, but lack a certain je ne sais quoi..

    Mons. Frosty Le Païen

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: